Deal breaker

14/Jun/2012

Comments: 1 reader has left a comment

CHRISTIAN Porter's decision to quit state politics and challenge for the federal seat of Pearce certainly took the State by surprise. But he has good reasons for doing so.

As Porter quickly found out while Treasurer, WA's GST share continues to slide and the ability of state governments to act independently of the Commonwealth is in decline.

He wants to do something about this in the only theatre where he can: federal politics.

But first Porter will have to win over Liberal Party preselectors and then the local public in Pearce. The later shouldn't be too hard given the safe nature of the seat.

The former is less certain. Despite being head and shoulders above other candidates, Porter hasn't been able to campaign for preselection until now.

Had he done so, his tightly-held decision to shift parliaments would have leaked ahead of time.

Two myths (in my view) have surfaced since Porter's announcement: that it's a selfish move and it leaves the state government in the lurch.

What could be more selfish than staying in state politics to become premier one day just because he can?

That would have denied Liberals the chance to plan for a future leadership change to someone passionate about running the state, as Colin Barnett is now.

The notion that state Liberals have been left in the lurch is easily dismissed by looking at the likely replacements for Porter in his twin portfolios.

Troy Buswell should step into the treasury portfolio he previously held, and his economic know-how is second to none.

North Metropolitan MLC Michael Mischin was a more senior state prosecutor than Porter before entering parliament, making him more than capable of taking over the Attorney General portfolio.

Porter is talented, so to that extent he is a loss to WA state politics. But if successful at his tilt at federal politics, Porter's move to Canberra will be WA's gain, the electorate of Pearce's in particular.

* Peter van Onselen is a Winthrop Professor and Chair of Journalism at UWA


Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

Fox

14/06/2012

Mischin was a more senior prosecutor than Porter, you can say that again. Porter wasn't senior at all with his criminal law and policy knowledge being suspect at best. He has made a debacle of our justice system since his appointment as AG. His claim to fame ( or perhaps shame) has been the enactment of draconian legislation and the building of more prisons ( he's anything but a strategic thinker).. He has been a blight on this State as AG and so many will be so pleased to see him go. Would that the blithering blunderbuss Johnson would also take off...

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Wednesday 22 May 2013

  • Min 7°C
  • Max 21°C

Thursday

  • 9 - 22°C

Friday

  • 9 - 23°C

Featured Video Clips

Subiaco's Cinemas Project

Western Suburbs Weekly reporter Erienne Lette and City of Subiaco Mayor Heather Henderson talks about the new Cinemas Project.

Oliver Hill Gun Battery

Editor Denise Cahill talks with Harriet Wyatt about new conservation and restoration works being done to the Oliver Hill Battery.

Cat Haven Update

Western Suburbs Weekly journalist Sarah Motherwell with this week's Cat Haven update.

Dog Refuge Update

Western Suburbs Weekly journalist Erienne Lette with this week's Dog Refuge update.

email subscribe link
CommunityPix banner linkCarbonFootie